AI harms animals due to mistake or misadventure in the way the AI operates in practice
The development and operation of AI systems causing environmental harm, such as through energy consumption of data centers, or material and carbon footprints associated with AI hardware.
Supporting Evidence (3)
Example: "precision livestock farming systems malfunction or operate in unintentional ways that harm animals"(p. 12)
"Consider a black-box AI system that provides too much or too little food or medicine to an animal in an automated environment such as a farm, zoo, or home without providing an understandable explanation for its actions (Miller, 2019). Such errors may only be discovered later (if at all) when animals get sick or sicker, by which time harm has been done."(p. 18)
"Future harm could result from AI operating with relatively high intelligence and autonomy in achieving its goals (Russell, 2019). Stuart Russell half humorously suggests that a robot chef which runs out of meat might decide to cook the cat (Havens, 2015). But something vaguely similar might occur and is worth pre-empting. For example, an advanced robot on a fruit and vegetable farm may decide to destroy small animals that enter the farm by ‘reasoning’ that they threaten the valuable produce."(p. 19)
Part of Unintentional: direct
Other risks from Coghlan & Parker (2023) (11)
Intentional: socially condemned/illegal
6.6 Environmental harmIntentional: socially condemned/illegal > AI intentionally designed and used to harm animals in ways that contradict social values or are illegal
6.6 Environmental harmIntentional: socially condemned/illegal > AI designed to benefit animals, humans, or ecosystems is intentionally abused to harm animals in ways that contradict social values or are illegal
6.6 Environmental harmIntentional: socially accepted/legal
6.6 Environmental harmUnintentional: direct
6.6 Environmental harmUnintentional: direct > AI is designed in a way that shows ignorant, reckless, or prejudiced lack of consideration for its impact on animals
6.6 Environmental harm